Priced Under $25

MMMMM. GOOD.
Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Sponge Candy Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Sponge Candy Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Sponge Candy

Buffalo's Best Sponge Candy
From $17.95
Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Chocolates Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Chocolates Watson's Chocolates Buffalo Chocolates

Buffalo Bites
$15.95
Turtlettes Turtlettes Turtlettes

Turtlettes
From $18.75
Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels

Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels
From $8.95
Deluxe Assortment Deluxe Assortment Deluxe Assortment

Deluxe Assortment
From $18.50
Watson's Buttercrunch in tiny white bowls Watson's Buttercrunch in tiny white bowls Watson's Buttercrunch in tiny white bowls

Watson's Best Buttercrunch
From $16.50
Chocolate Covered Popcorn Chocolate Covered Popcorn Chocolate Covered Popcorn

Chocolate Covered Popcorn
From $15.95
Chocolate fruit and nut clusters Chocolate fruit and nut clusters Chocolate fruit and nut clusters

Chocolate Clusters
From $15.95
assortment of chocolate truffles assortment of chocolate truffles assortment of chocolate truffles

Truffle Assortment
From $7.15 $8.95 21% OFF
Peanut Butter Minuettes Peanut Butter Minuettes

Peanut Butter Minuettes
$16.25
Chocolate covered oreos Chocolate covered oreos Chocolate covered oreos

Chocolate Covered Oreos
From $6.35 $7.95 21% OFF
Chocolate Covered Pretzels - minis Chocolate Covered Pretzels - minis

Chocolate Covered Pretzels - minis
$15.95
Various Chocolate suckers Various Chocolate suckers

Everyday Chocolate Suckers
From $1.99
chocolate nonpareils chocolate nonpareils

Nonpareils
$15.95
Large bone shaped dog biscuits Large bone shaped dog biscuits

Bela's Dog Biscuits
$8.95
Chocolate mints stacked on top of each other Chocolate mints stacked on top of each other

Watson's Hostess Mints
$19.95
Watson's 9-piece deluxe assortment box Watson's 9-piece deluxe assortment box

Deluxe Assortment 9-piece
$11.50
16-Piece Sweet Box of Assorted Chocolates 16-Piece Sweet Box of Assorted Chocolates 16-Piece Sweet Box of Assorted Chocolates

16-Piece Sweet Box of Assorted Chocolates
$19.25
various chocolate emoji suckers various chocolate emoji suckers

Emoji Suckers
$2.95
Various halloween themed chocolate suckers Various halloween themed chocolate suckers

Halloween Suckers
From $1.99
half of a sponge candy and Toffee Topping jar half of a sponge candy and Toffee Topping jar

Sponge Candy Toffee Topping
$8.95
Chocolate spiders Chocolate spiders Chocolate spiders

Chocolate Spiders
$19.50
chocolate covered peanuts, raisins, almonds, cashews, blueberries and cherries in a bowl chocolate covered peanuts, raisins, almonds, cashews, blueberries and cherries in a bowl

Signature Bridge Mix
$17.25
Original Hot Fudge Jar Original Hot Fudge Jar

Watson's Original Hot Fudge Sauce
$8.95
Dark and Milk Chocolate minis Dark and Milk Chocolate minis Dark and Milk Chocolate minis

Everyday Chocolate Minis
$19.50
Elmwood Strip Bar Elmwood Strip Bar

Elmwood Strip Bar
$5.95
Watson's Assortment with Sponge Candy Watson's Assortment with Sponge Candy Watson's Assortment with Sponge Candy

Watson's Assortment with Sponge Candy
$14.95
2-piece Sponge Candy 2-piece Sponge Candy 2-piece Sponge Candy

Sponge Candy Favor, 2-piece
$3.95
Chocolate Buffalo Cookie Cutter Chocolate Buffalo Cookie Cutter

BuffaLOVE - Chocolate Buffalo Cookie Cutter
$6.95
Mighty Bill Buffalo Milk and dark chocolate Mighty Bill Buffalo Milk and dark chocolate Mighty Bill Buffalo Milk and dark chocolate

Mighty Buffalo Bill
$11.95
Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter

Chocolate Heart Cookie Cutter
$4.25
Chocolate Novelties Chocolate Novelties

Chocolate Novelties
From $3.99
Sponge Candy Tote Sponge Candy Tote Sponge Candy Tote

Sponge Candy Tote
$9.95
Fall Foiled Leaves Fall Foiled Leaves

Fall Foiled Leaves
$15.95
#buffalobestspongecandy white mug #buffalobestspongecandy white mug #buffalobestspongecandy white mug

Watson's Sponge Candy Mug
$15.95
horseshoe-shaped chocolates horseshoe-shaped chocolates

Chocolate Horseshoe
$3.95
Cupcake sized Charlie Chaplin Chocolate Cupcake sized Charlie Chaplin Chocolate Cupcake sized Charlie Chaplin Chocolate

Charlie Chaplin
$10.50
Chocolate Football Chocolate Football

Chocolate Football
$3.95
Packaged 4-piece dark chocolate sponge candy Packaged 4-piece dark chocolate sponge candy Packaged 4-piece dark chocolate sponge candy

Sponge Candy Favor 4-piece
$5.95
Watson's Gift card Watson's Gift card Watson's Gift card

Gift Card
From $10.00
Chocolate buffalo cookie cutter favor Chocolate buffalo cookie cutter favor Chocolate buffalo cookie cutter favor

BuffaLOVE Favor- Chocolate Buffalo Cookie Cutter
$6.50
2-piece truffle in a box 2-piece truffle in a box 2-piece truffle in a box

Watson's 2-piece Truffle Favor
$3.95
4 piece truffle on a dessert plate 4 piece truffle on a dessert plate 4 piece truffle on a dessert plate

Watson's 4-piece Truffle Favor
$6.50
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Favor, 6-piece mini Chocolate Covered Pretzel Favor, 6-piece mini Chocolate Covered Pretzel Favor, 6-piece mini

Chocolate Covered Pretzel Favor, 6-piece mini
$3.95
Chocolate Pumpkin Chocolate Pumpkin

Chocolate Pumpkin
$3.99
Chocolate covered oreo favor Chocolate covered oreo favor Chocolate covered oreo favor

Chocolate Covered Oreo Favor
$2.95
Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter Watson's Milk chocolate in a heart-shaped cookie cutter

Chocolate Heart Cookie Cutter Favor
$4.25
Watson's various fudge bars Watson's various fudge bars

Watson's Fudge Bar
$18.95
Chocolate Turkey Sucker Chocolate Turkey Sucker

Chocolate Turkey Sucker
$1.99
Solid Chocolate Witch Solid Chocolate Witch

Solid Chocolate Witch
$6.50